SRG stands for correctly researched and verified information, with journalistically trained editors and journalists who adhere to media laws. This enables neutral opinion formation and is central to democracy. Contribution cuts are dangerous.
Convinced? Rate this contribution from the community — and help make the best ideas visible.
8 comments
Join the discussion: ask questions, challenge ideas, and add context so the post becomes clearer.
1000 characters remaining
R. P.
4 months ago
@Thomas: I don't see any danger of contribution cuts here. On the contrary: If the media contributions can be divided among different media houses (they are not cut, just distributed differently), a greater diversity of opinions emerges, because SRG only spreads its own opinion and does not allow other opinions. It excludes all people (and documents) who could question its own opinion. Therefore it would be good to have more strong media houses that could close this information gap.
0
R. P.
4 months ago
SRF reports very selectively. An example: The meeting minutes of the Robert Koch Institute, where the corona measures were discussed and recommended, were released in Germany. SRF still refuses to report on them. Even though it was reprimanded by the independent complaint authority and should actually do so.
SRF hätte über RKI-Protokolle berichten müssen
The Federal Council also oriented its measures accordingly. So it would be important. But because the minutes contain things that SRF has always denied (e.g., political influence), they cannot report neutrally without criticizing their own coverage. Therefore it is simply silenced.
0
T. L.
4 months ago
@Renato Could you please clarify what your critical comment about the questionable handling by SRG of the reprimand for the problem discussed here “membership fee cuts are dangerous” means? Does it need more money so that it can be processed cleanly?
We are in danger of discussing who has power over the supply and not how much money we are willing to pay.
1
R. P.
4 months ago
@Thomas The example is unfortunately still very current: To this day SRF refuses to comply with the reprimand of the UBI. And in autumn the new pandemic law will be introduced, which wants to write all measures of 2020 into law. It is highly undemocratic to spread only one-sided information about it. SRF is obliged to report neutrally and not just push its own opinion. It has not done so to date: Not a single critic of the measures was ever invited and the “review” consisted of asking its own journalists whether they thought they had been well informed. What my opinion on this is does not matter here. It is about official information that underlies the measures. Withholding this from the audience because the SRF editorial staff disagrees is not neutral. SRF must have the courage to also criticize the Federal Council, otherwise it is a compliant state broadcaster.
0
T. L.
4 months ago
An example from 2024, and at the same time the period that is surrounded by a lot of polemics. It isn’t particularly convincing when you consider how much has been published in the meantime. Yes, I understand the point, although SRF reports actively on it, it takes a different position than expected.
From privately‑owned media, one can expect less transparency here, in my view.
Nevertheless: the Republic is independent and reports accurately and verifiably. However, that costs me annually (in relation to the benefit) much more than the radio and television fee. Thus, it is not only the SRG that stands for quality.
1
D. M.
4 months ago
Independent reporting must also be able to correct itself or always reflect the current state of knowledge, even if it contrasts with earlier reporting. News means constantly realigning itself according to the changing reality.
Therefore it is welcome when the contribution can be freely distributed for independent information – explicitly to all publishers – regardless of the medium and the represented opinion. Who pays will decide!
0
D. M.
4 months ago
I disagree with all the claims of Problem #5. I think the SRG is as good or as bad as the media average. Because payment is made without quality or performance, there is no incentive to produce a good product or to meet the consumer's desire, which I notice as a consumer.
Just as a plant grows better when it is pruned, community‑funded projects should not simply be allowed to grow unchecked - cuts can keep them healthy.
3
T. L.
4 months ago
As a representative of the majority “I agree,” a proof of their quality rating “average” might make me somewhat skeptical.
In my view, the argument that the lack of incentive is based on this does not hold. The content is produced by people who rely on their salaries. Poor quality leads to job loss—if that isn’t market‑driven, what is?
By demanding cuts, they presumably want to increase the pressure. However, this will not achieve the goal of having the remaining people write news in their own sense. If I try to put myself in their shoes, my reaction would be strong criticism of the red pen and the reduced diversity. Under pressure, diamonds may form, but not serious news.
The last decades of the media landscape and advertising have led to a battle for consumer attention. It is demonstrable that reports on disasters and tragedies gain traction.