Convinced? Rate this contribution from the community — and help make the best ideas visible.
3 comments
Join the discussion: ask questions, challenge ideas, and add context so the post becomes clearer.
1000 characters remaining
Former member
3 weeks ago
As far as I understand the research, advertising does not lead to increased consumption. Advertising cannot create a need. Advertising is meant to ensure that when you have a need, the advertising company appears as the best option in your mind.
The problem with advertising is therefore primarily that it is a pure waste of resources.
In public spaces, advertising is not only ugly but also particularly burdensome. Advertising is an extremely unnecessary part of the information deluge that overwhelms our brains.
1
O. H.Moderation
3 weeks ago
Resource waste and information overload are strong arguments in their own right. Would you like to capture two new problem statements? Then the community can evaluate them.
1
O. H.Moderation
3 weeks ago
Thank you for the comment.
Part of it is correct: advertising shifts between brands, and individual campaigns often have weak effects. A study of 288 brands found that TV advertising usually only had small effects on sales (Shapiro et al., Econometrica 2021).
However, it is not correct that advertising does not increase overall consumption. Comprehensive tobacco advertising bans reduced consumption in 22 OECD countries by about 6 percent (Saffer and Chaloupka 2000). Children eat more of unhealthy foods after advertising for them (Boyland et al. 2016). For the US, Molinari and Turino (2018) estimate that advertising increases total consumption. However, how strong billboard advertising actually is remains little researched.